This contest has ended! Thanks to our hundreds of voters.
➡️ See who won!
Which Erie pizza place would you drive across town for — every single time? Cast your vote in Erie’s Ultimate Pizza Showdown and help us crown Erie’s favorite pizza place just in time for National Pizza Day on February 9.
Your vote helps decide which pizza place takes the top spot in Erie — and one lucky voter will score a $25 gift card to their favorite spot. Because yes, free pizza does taste better.
Voting is only open for a few days — don’t wait!
Vote here now:
How it works
- Vote for one Erie pizza place (listed alphabetically)
- Don’t see your favorite? Choose “Other” and write it in
- Only one vote per email address per day will be counted
- Voting is open for just a few days, so don’t wait!
🗓️ Voting closes midnight February 8, 2026
🏆 Winner announced on National Pizza Day — February 9, 2026
What’s in it for you?
- You help decide Erie’s favorite pizza place
- You’re entered to win a $25 pizza gift card
- The winning pizzeria will be featured on Macaroni KID Erie
Why we love this
Erie’s pizza scene is packed with incredible local spots, and everyone has strong opinions. This showdown is our way of celebrating them all — and giving local families a fun reason to rally behind their favorite slice.
Grab a napkin, trust your gut, and cast your vote. 🍕❤️
Ready to vote?
Help us crown Erie’s Ultimate Pizza Champion!
Cast Your Vote Now!
P.S. Don’t forget to share this contest with your friends and family—the more votes, the better the showdown! And hey, who doesn’t love pizza?
